Tuesday, August 28, 2007

Films to Watch Part 1: The Future of Food

This is a documentary that I will be thinking about for a long time. I think it is really important for everyone who eats food to see this. If you'd rather just read my synopsis, here it is (but if you plan to see the film, you may want to stop reading now):

In the 19th century, there were 7000 kinds of apples and 5000 kinds of potatoes grown in the world. Now, 90% of those varieties are extinct. There are only 4 kinds of potatoes commonly grown today. With less biodiversity, crops are more vulnerable to pests and drought. It has put farmers on a pesticide treadmill. The nitrogen bombs used during World War II led to the technology that gave us nitrogen fertilizers, while nerve gas led to insecticides. Both have led to polluted water.

In the 1980s, Monsanto introduced Round-Up herbicides. In the 1990's, they introduced genetically modified seeds called "Round-Up Ready." To create these seeds, they put genes that are resistant to the herbicides directly into the plant's DNA using bacteria and viruses. Now, Monsanto sells the farmer both the herbicide and the seed. The thing that is most concerning of all about this is that, once released into the environment, the spread of these new genes cannot be controlled.

The US patent office did not allow the patenting of living things until 1978, when thay allowed the patenting of an oil-eating microbe. That microbe was never used, but the case opened the way for corporations to begin patenting human genes, body parts, species, and seeds. One result is that a company patented the breat cancer gene, and has limited research for a cure. Monsanto, Dupont, and ConAgra bought every seed company and patented them all. Over the last two decades, they have also staffed the FDA and the EPA with Monsanto executives.

A farmer in Canada named Percy Schmeiser has been using canola seeds derived from those used by his grandparents his whole life. One day, Monsanto came onto his property, sampled his plants, and discovered some with Round-Up Ready technology. The demanded that he purchase a license. He fought the company in the courts because he did not choose to use Round-Up Ready plants; the seeds had blown onto his property. After years of litigation, during which time he had to destroy his entire store of seeds, the Canadian Supreme Court decided in favor of Monsanto saying that the farmer's plants were Monsanto's property. There are estimates that 9000 other farmers have been forced to settle with Monsanto, and now pay them a license fee.

In the United States, the government does not require testing or labelling of genetically modified (GMO) foods. Japan, Iceland, and the European Union require labelling, which makes it harder for US farmers to sell their products there. Mexico banned GMO corn to protect their heritage of native corn varieties, but GMO seeds have been spreading into the country anyway.

Right now, there are only 5 genetically modified crops grown: corn, soybeans, canola, cotton, and wheat. Many other GMO crops are in the development stages, including what is known as a 'terminator gene.' This will render a plant's offspring infertile and require the farmer to buy all of their seeds from a supplier. The problem is, if this gene gets out and cross-pollinates with other plants in the wild, it could be devastating for the environment.

Polls have shown that American consumers would prefer to have genetically modified food to be labelled as such, so that they can choose whether or not to buy it. Since 2000, senators Dennis Kucinich and Barbara Boxer have repeatedly introduced the The Genetically Engineered Food Right-to-Know Act, S. 2080. If you support this act, please let your senator know. Meanwhile, the best way to avoid buying GMO food is to buy organic fruits and vegetables, or to buy directly from local farmers who do not use genetically modified seeds.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Yes! To say this film is important would be an understatement. I think it could go on to be recognized as the Silent Spring of the new millennium.

Monsanto is such an evil company. I don't throw terms like "evil" around lightly... but any organization that would persecute simple farmers and force them into licensed slavery deserves the name.

There is a great article in the August 27th issue of The New Yorker which examines some of the issues raised by The Future of Food. It is called Annals of Agriculture: Sowing for the Apocalypse by John Seabrook (unfortunately, I think the online version is subscription-only.) It's a fascinating and disturbing investigation into efforts to develop a global "seed bank". The seed bank would follow models already in place throughout history (even ancient farmers understood the necessity of storing seeds between seasons.) It would be a high-tech storage facility dedicated to preserving viable samples of the vast variety of "heritage" seedlings around the world.

A large part of the article concerns the role companies like Monsanto have played in the modern global agricultural system. The legal recognition of patents on seeds has been a major transformation; one of financial benefit to behemoths like Monsanto, and financial ruin to small farmers-- especially those in developing countries. (It should come as no surprise that farmers in Iraq who accepted U.S. "recovery assistance" did so at the price of entering into contracts that force them to buy American-patented seeds every season...!)

Probably the most disturbing part of the article, to me, was the description of the decline in variety among harvested foods. Whereas one hundred years ago, there might be hundreds of varieties of farmed apples, there are now only a handful to be found (especially at national-chain, non-organic, non-locally-grown groceries As anyone can attest, those generic apples may be huge-- but also flavorless and bland.) Among staple crops, such as corn, the situation is even more dire. Why? History has the answer. Homogenous populations (such as a single variety of corn) will eventually prove to have an Achilles Heel of susceptibility to disease of some kind... such as the Irish potato famine. The trend toward corporate-owned "mono-crops" makes this all the more frightening. When the nation's supply of corn is all one patented, engineered variety, the inevitable appearance of a natural disease will be disastrous. The over-engineered and fragile mega-crops would collapse into blight and rot, with no other varieties to substitute. The effect on the world would be profound. For America alone, within just weeks the foundation of the nation's food chain would be decimated.

The short-sighted greed that drives "technological enhancement" to farming is not only bad for variety-- it's a long-term prescription for disaster. The one bright spot on the horizon is the growing desire among consumers for the taste and assortment of organic, locally-grown foods (many from "heirloom" seed sources.) Hopefully the long-term will see such demand create a parallel infrastructure-- so that when Monsanto's tomatoes suddenly wilt off the factory-farm vines, Farmer Bob's heirloom varieties will fill the void on suburban kitchen counters in all their yellow, orange, and deep red glory-- and families everywhere will say "you mean tomatoes actually taste this GOOD???"